Thursday, March 17, 2011

How We Managed to Make a Decision

   On the weekend before the class I looked at the syllabus to get an idea about what we will be talking in class and  maybe just to briefly read through the material. It says "Review Exam #1 / Decision making". Hmm, I wondered to myself, how professor can manage to put these two together if mostly he has not enough time to cover entire chapter in class? But I still took my text book and reviewed the chapter.
   The class didn't promise anything extraordinary until I heard professor saying  - "You have time to decide...". I instantly knew that it was one of the class activities and I told this to one of my classmates. It was a pleasure to see all these people come up to the blackboard and try make 80 people to listen to what they have to say. But the best job did the girl from the first row (sorry, do not remember the name) - not only I enjoyed her voice, but she also seemed so calm along the whole process, successfully leading the mass of overexcited people, trying to avoid the chaos.
   I personally don't like openly participate in discussions where such a mass of people involved, because you never know the outcome. Plus I do not like scream over someone who is already speaking loud. That is making me not being aggressive, nor assertive. But there were more then enough people wanting to win over the audience and have their voice heard.Some people tried to come up and eventually gave up and went back to their seats, but some stayed and proved to be real leaders.
   I was avoiding the process - I was very participant amount my neighbors-classmates. We shared our opinions left and right, what would be good for us and what else could be added to the list of "MUST HAVE" or "MUST HAVE NOT".
   I was not a mediator among extreme opinions, but our number #1 leader was able to manage it very brilliantly. I liked that she was not demanding, but was asking "what if..." - that kind of questions are very soothing to everyone's ears. Than I was absolutely shocked in a good way when one of the girls said "his opinion is important", referring to that person who did not want to vote on our proposal. Usually people in large quantities tend not to pay attention to those who do not agree with majority, and if not for professor mentioning that only unanimous vote will count it would probably be the case.
   When it comes to accommodation I think that in our decision making class everyone was trying to accommodate their own interests. And there is an example - when someone proposed to the class to make first exam to be worth less overall points, people who got more was complaining because their didn't want to loose their good grade over people who did do that good on the test.
   I believe that collaboration was more between the group and professor. Everyone were still looking at the professor and his reaction on what we were trying to get out of this, and some of the stuff got shut down eventually in a process of decision making. There were also voices among people sitting at the back of the classroom screaming "how about this?" and "how about that?"; at the end of the class I felt that everyone just wanted to get something then nothing and that is how we agreed to what we had written on a board, which wasn't a bad scenario for all of us.
   I am absolutely positive that every single one of us learned something new from the "experiment". It is a real life situation and I am glad that no one got hurt along the way.

6 comments:

  1. I was in a similar situation as you. I don't like screaming over people, but with the people near me, we all said our opinions about the decisions being made. We also gave different ideas about the grading part of the exercise. Unfortunately, since the ideas weren't the majority's choice, one of the girl's idea wasn't given a chance to be fully heard. Well, the class was fun and interesting, and like you said, we all did get something out of it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agreed I'm not a fan of getting in a screaming match with over 70 people. However like you, I did discuss the options with my neighbors and we talked about what would work and what wouldn't.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey, at least you had kind of a knowledge that it was an "experiment." I had suspected it at the beginning but seeing the amount of chaos that ensued, I started thinking: "No way our professor would let this much anarchy slide; this must just be about the exam." Plus, I was emotionally involved regarding the essay and completely forgot about the fact that this might have been an exercise, which I think turned out to be a good thing. Had I known it was an exercise, my reactions and thought processes would have been different, and considering how much I have learned from that one day, I am very glad I did not know it was an exercise.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I also the girls courage to stand in the front and the way she handled the situation. At least your rows people were discussing on it but in my row we just sat and laugh. It was fun at the same time and learning at the same time. The way professor made the projects are amazing and this way we can always remember them in future.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I felt the same way you did. Because screaming from everywhere was not helping to anyone. Thanks to the lady in the front to have everybody organized and made the most proper decision.

    ReplyDelete
  6. As always,Maryna, your post is interesting to read and I agree on a few points with you here. I think too that the girl in front - natural leader did a great job by managing all of us without imposing her own opinion. And it's hard to be in front of the people who has too many different ideas shooting your way :)Just like you I felt no need to scream across the room, so I shared my thoughts with the students next to me. And yes, it is a real life situation, so now you have some kind of idea of what actions you gonna take when "chaos" will hit you :)

    ReplyDelete